Icon-facebook Twitter Youtube Pinterest-p
Claim Form

Landmark Case Laws

Running a business is unpredictable, and when unforeseen circumstances such as natural disasters, pandemics, or other disruptive events cause financial losses, it can have a devastating impact on your livelihood. Business Interruption Insurance is designed to compensate businesses for lost income due to events that prevent normal business operations. However, claims can often be complex and time-consuming, and insurers may try to minimise payouts.

At Claim Way, we specialise in handling business interruption claims, ensuring that your business is fairly compensated for its losses. Whether your business has been affected by floods, FIRES, OR EVEN THE GLOBAL PANDEMIC, WE WILL ASSIST YOU IN NAVIGATING THE COMPLEXITIES OF YOUR INSURANCE POLICY AND ENSURING THAT YOUR CLAIM IS PROCESSED PROMPTLY.

CEREBRAL PALSY CASE LAW

Case: Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board [2015] UKSC 11

  • Facts: Nadine Montgomery, who was a diabetic, gave birth to a baby who developed cerebral palsy due to complications during childbirth. The baby’s shoulder became stuck during delivery (shoulder dystocia), and there was a delay in performing a caesarean section. Mrs. Montgomery was not warned of the risk of shoulder dystocia or the option of a caesarean section, which could have prevented the injury.
  • Decision & Compensation: The Supreme Court ruled in favour of Montgomery, and although the specific compensation amount was not publicly disclosed, it is reported that damages could have reached £5 million to cover lifetime care, medical treatment, and loss of earnings.
  • Impact: This case established the duty of medical professionals to disclose material risks to patients, significantly affecting cerebral palsy and other birth injury claims related to informed consent.

BRACHIAL PLEXUS INJURIES (ERB’S PALSY) CASE LAW

Case: H V Kings College Hospital NHS Foundation Trust [2019]

  • Facts: A baby was born with Erb’s palsy after the midwife applied excessive traction to the baby’s head during delivery, causing damage to the brachial plexus nerves. This was a case of shoulder dystocia that was not handled according to proper procedures.
  • Decision & Compensation: The court found the hospital liable for medical negligence. The compensation awarded was £500,000 to cover the child’s ongoing medical treatment, therapy, and adaptations needed due to the permanent nature of the injury.
  • Impact: This case reinforces the duty of healthcare professionals to manage complicated deliveries properly, especially when shoulder dystocia is present. Compensation in Erb’s palsy cases often includes costs for long-term therapy and care.

FRACTURES AND BROKEN BONES CASE LAW

Case: Gower v Saxton [2004]

  • Facts: A baby sustained a fractured clavicle during delivery as a result of the improper use of ventouse (vacuum extraction). The claimant argued that the doctor applied excessive force during delivery, causing the injury.
  • Decision & Compensation: The court ruled in favour of the claimant, awarding £40,000 in compensation to cover the pain and suffering endured by the baby, medical expenses, and any temporary care required during recovery.
  • Impact: The case illustrates the importance of correctly using delivery instruments to prevent avoidable birth injuries such as fractures. Although these injuries often heal, compensation accounts for pain and potential complications.

HYPOXIA (OXYGEN DEPRIVATION) CASE LAW

Case: JP v Berkshire Healthcare NHS Trust [2017]

  • Facts: A baby suffered hypoxia (oxygen deprivation) during childbirth, resulting in cerebral palsy. There was a delay in performing an emergency caesarean section, despite signs of foetal distress.
  • Decision & Compensation : The court found the hospital negligent and awarded £14 million to cover lifetime care, therapy, assistive devices, and medical treatment, as well as loss of future earnings.
  • Impact: This case underscores the importance of timely medical intervention to prevent brain injuries like cerebral palsy caused by hypoxia. Compensation in hypoxia cases often reflects the lifelong care and support required for the injured child.

FACIAL NERVE DAMAGE CASE LAW

Case: X v Y NHS Trust [2002]

  • Facts: A baby suffered facial nerve damage during delivery due to the improper use of forceps , resulting in temporary facial paralysis. The claimant argued that the forceps were applied with excessive force during delivery.
  • Decision & Compensation: The court ruled in favour of the claimant and awarded £30,000 in compensation for the pain, suffering, and psychological impact of the temporary paralysis, as well as the cost of medical treatment to aid recovery.
  • Impact: This case highlights the risks associated with forceps deliveries and underscores the importance of careful handling by medical professionals. Compensation accounts for the medical treatment and emotional distress associated with facial nerve damage .

STILLBIRTH OR NEONATAL DEATH CASE LAW

Case: RE v Calderdale & Huddersfield NHS Foundation Trust [2017]

  • Facts: A mother experienced a stillbirth after the hospital failed to perform an emergency caesarean section in response to signs of foetal distress. The parents claimed that medical negligence led to the death of their baby.
  • Decision & Compensation: The court found the hospital negligent and awarded £100,000 in compensation for the emotional suffering of the parents, as well as funeral expenses and other associated costs.
  • Impact: The case illustrates the profound emotional and financial impact of stillbirth or neonatal death caused by medical negligence. While no amount of compensation can undo such a loss, it can help cover the financial burden associated with the tragedy.

SUMMARY OF COMPENSATION AWARDS

TYPE OF INJURY CASE COMPENSATION AWARDED
Cerebral Palsy Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board [2015] £5 million (approx.)
Brachial Plexus (Erb’s Palsy) H v Kings College Hospital NHS [2019] £500,000
Fractures and Broken Bones Gower v Saxton [2004] £40,000
Hypoxia (Oxygen Deprivation) JP v Berkshire Healthcare NHS [2017] £14 million
Facial Nerve Damage X v Y NHS Trust [2002] £30,000
Stillbirth or Neonatal Death RE v Calderdale & Huddersfield NHS [2017] £100,000

These case briefs now include the compensation amounts awarded to the claimants, demonstrating the range of financial settlements that are available depending on the severity of the injury and the impact on the claimant’s life. If you need further details or clarification, feel free to ask!